|Advances in Vision-Based Lane Detection: Algorithms, Integration, Assessment, and Perspectives on ACP-Based Parallel Vision
|Yang Xing1, Chen Lv2, Long Chen3, Huaji Wang2, Hong Wang4, Dongpu Cao4, Efstathios Velenis2, Fei-Yue Wang5
|1. Advanced Vehicle Engineering Centre, Cranfield University, Bedford MK43 0AL, U. K., and also with Vehicle Intelligence Pioneers Ltd, Qingdao, 266000, China;
2. Advanced Vehicle Engineering Centre, Cranfield University, Bedford MK43 0AL, UK;
3. School of Data and Computer Science, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China;
4. Mechanical and Mechatronics Engineering with the University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West Waterloo, ON, N2L 3G1, Canada;
5. State Key Laboratory of Management and Control for Complex Systems, Institute of Automation, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
|  E.Bellis and J.Page,National motor vehicle crash causation survey (NMVCCS),SAS analytical users manual,U.S.Department of Transportation,National Highway Traffic Safety Administration,Washington,DC,USA,Tech.Rep.No.HS-811053,Dec.2008.
 J.E.Gayko, "Lane departure and lane keeping," in Handbook of Intelligent Vehicles,A.Eskandarian,Ed.London,UK:Springer,2012,pp.689-708.
 C.Visvikis,T.L.Smith,M.Pitcher,and R.Smith, "Study on lane departure warning and lane change assistant systems," Transport Research Laboratory,Berks,UK,Transport Research Laboratory Project Rep.PPR,2008,pp.374.
 A.Bar Hillel,R.Lerner,D.Levi,and G.Raz, "Recent progress in road and lane detection:A survey," Mach.Vis.Appl.,vol.25,no.3,pp.727-745,Apr.2014.
 J.C.McCall and M.M.Trivedi, "Video-based lane estimation and tracking for driver assistance:Survey,system,and evaluation," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.7,no.1,pp.20-37,Mar.2006.
 S.Yenikaya,G.Yenikaya,and E.Duven, "Keeping the vehicle on the road:A survey on on-road lane detection systems," ACM Comput.Surv.(CSUR),vol.46,no.1,pp.2,2013.
 J.Fritsch,T.Kuhnl,and A.Geiger, "A new performance measure and evaluation benchmark for road detection algorithms," in Proc.16th Int.IEEE Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC 2013),The Hague,Netherlands,2013,pp.1693-1700.
 M.Beyeler,F.Mirus,and A.Verl, "Vision-based robust road lane detection in urban environments," in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Robotics and Automation (ICRA),Hong Kong,China,2014,pp.4920-4925.
 D.J.Kang,and M.H.Jung, "Road lane segmentation using dynamic programming for active safety vehicles," Pattern Recogn.Lett.,vol.24,no.16,pp.3177-3185,Dec.2003.
 U.Suddamalla,S.Kundu,S.Farkade,and A.Das, "A novel algorithm of lane detection addressing varied scenarios of curved and dashed lanemarks," in Proc.Int.Conf.Image Processing Theory,Tools and Applications (IPTA),Orleans,France,2015,pp.87-92.
 J.M.Collado,C.Hilario,A.de la Escalera,and J.M.Armingol, "Adaptative road lanes detection and classification," in Proc.8th Int.Conf.Advanced Concepts for Intelligent Vision Systems,Springer,2006,pp.1151-1162.
 S.Sehestedt,S.Kodagoda,A.Alempijevic,and G.Dissanayake, "Robust lane detection in urban environments," in Proc.IEEE/RSJ Int.Conf.Intelligent Robots and Systems,San Diego,CA,USA,2007,pp.123-128.
 Q.Lin,Y.Han,and H.Hahn, "Real-time lane departure detection based on extended edge-linking algorithm," in Proc.2nd Int.Conf.Computer Research and Development,Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia,2010,pp.725-730.
 A.F.Cela,L.M.Bergasa,F.L.Sánchez,and M.A.Herrera, "Lanes detection based on unsupervised and adaptive classifier," in Proc.5th Int.Conf.Computational Intelligence,Communication Systems and Networks (CICSyN),Madrid,Spain,2013,pp.228-233.
 A.Borkar,M.Hayes,M.T.Smith,and S.Pankanti, "A layered approach to robust lane detection at night," in Proc.IEEE Workshop on Computational Intelligence in Vehicles and Vehicular Systems,Nashville,TN,USA,2009,pp.51-57.
 C.Kreucher and S.Lakshmanan, "LANA:A lane extraction algorithm that uses frequency domain features," IEEE Trans.Robot.Autom.,vol.15,no.2,pp.343-350,Apr.1999.
 S.Jung,J.Youn,and S.Sull, "Efficient lane detection based on spatiotemporal images," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.17,no.1,pp.289-295,Jan.2016.
 J.Xiao,S.T.Li,and B.Sun, "A real-time system for lane detection based on FPGA and DSP," Sens.Imag.,vol.17,no.1,pp.6,Dec.2016.
 U.Ozgunalp and N.Dahnoun, "Lane detection based on improved feature map and efficient region of interest extraction," in Proc.IEEE Global Conf.Signal and Information Processing (GlobalSIP),Orlando,FL,USA,2015,pp.923-927.
 Y.Wang,D.G.Shen,and E.K.Teoh, "Lane detection using spline model," Pattern Recogn.Lett.,vol.21,no.8,pp.677-689,Jul.2000.
 Y.Wang,E.K.Teoh,and D.G.Shen, "Lane detection and tracking using B-Snake," Image Vis.Comput.,vol.22,no.4,pp.269-280,Apr.2004.
 X.Y.Li,X.Z.Fang,C.Wang,and W.Zhang, "Lane detection and tracking using a parallel-snake approach," J.Intell.Robot.Syst.,vol.77,no.3-4,pp.597-609,Mar.2015.
 K.H.Lim,K.P.Seng,and L.M.Ang, "River flow lane detection and Kalman filtering-based B-spline lane tracking," Int.J.Veh.Technol.,vol.2012,pp.465819,Nov.2012.
 C.R.Jung and C.R.Kelber, "An improved linear-parabolic model for lane following and curve detection," in Proc.18th Brazilian Symp.Computer Graphics and Image Processing (SIBGRAPI'05),Natal,Rio Grande do Norte,Brazil,2005,pp.131-138.
 M.Aly, "Real time detection of lane markers in urban streets," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Eindhoven,Netherlands,2008,pp.7-12.
 A.Borkar,M.Hayes,and M.T.Smith, "Robust lane detection and tracking with ransac and Kalman filter," in Proc.16th IEEE Int.Conf.Image Processing (ICIP),Cairo,Egypt,2009,pp.3261-3264.
 A.Lopez,C.Canero,J.Serrat,J.Saludes,F.Lumbreras,and T.Graf, "Detection of lane markings based on ridgeness and RANSAC," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems,Vienna,Austria,2005,pp.254-259.
 A.Lopez,J.Serrat,C.Cañero,F.Lumbreras,and T.Graf, "Robust lane markings detection and road geometry computation," Int.J.Automot.Technol.,vol.11,no.3,pp.395-407,Jun.2010.
 Q.Chen and H.Wang, "A real-time lane detection algorithm based on a hyperbola-pair model," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Tokyo,Japan,2006,pp.510-515.
 H.C.Tan,Y.Zhou,Y.Zhu,D.Y.Yao,and J.Q.Wang, "Improved river flow and random sample consensus for curve lane detection," Adv.Mech.Eng.,vol.7,no.7,pp.1-12,Jul.2015.
 J.Hur,S.N.Kang,and S.W.Seo, "Multi-lane detection in urban driving environments using conditional random fields," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.(IV),Gold Coast,QLD,Australia,2013,1297-1302.
 F.Bounini,D.Gingras,V.Lapointe,and H.Pollart, "Autonomous vehicle and real time road lanes detection and tracking," in Proc.IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conf.(VPPC),Montreal,QC,Canada,2015,pp.1-6.
 D.Z.Wu,R.Zhao,and Z.H.Wei, "A multi-segment lane-switch algorithm for efficient real-time lane detection," in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Information and Automation (ICIA),Hailar,China,2014,pp.273-278.
 S.Y.Zhou,Y.H.Jiang,J.Q.Xi,J.W.Gong,G.M.Xiong,and H.Y.Chen, "A novel lane detection based on geometrical model and Gabor filter," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV),San Diego,CA,USA,2010,pp.59-64.
 J.W.Niu,J.Lu,M.L.Xu,P.Lv,and X.K.Zhao, "Robust lane detection using two-stage feature extraction with curve fitting," Pattern Recogn.,vol.59,pp.225-233,Nov.2016.
 B.He,R.Ai,Y.Yan,and X.P.Lang, "Lane marking detection based on Convolution Neural Network from point clouds," in Proc.19th Int.Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC),Rio de Janeiro,Brazil,2016,pp.2475-2480.
 J.Li,X.Mei,D.Prokhorov,and D.C.Tao, "Deep neural network for structural prediction and lane detection in traffic scene," IEEE Trans.Neural Netw.Learn.Syst.,vol.28,no.3,pp.690-703,Mar.2017.
 A.Gurghian,T.Koduri,S.V.Bailur,K.J.Carey,and V.N.Murali, "DeepLanes:End-to-end lane position estimation using deep neural networks," in Proc.IEEE Conf.Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition Workshops (CVPRW),Las Vegas,NV,USA,2016,pp.38-45.
 X.Li,Q.X.Wu,Y.Kou,L.Hou,and H.Yang, "Lane detection based on spiking neural network and Hough transform," in Proc.8th Int.Congr.Image and Signal Processing (CISP),Shenyang,China,2015,pp.626-630.
 J.Kim,J.Kim,G.J.Jang,and M.Lee, "Fast learning method for convolutional neural networks using extreme learning machine and its application to lane detection," Neural Netw.,vol.87,pp.109-121,Mar.2017.
 B.He,R.Ai,Y.Yan,and X.P.Lang, "Accurate and robust lane detection based on Dual-View Convolutional Neutral Network," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV),Gothenburg,Sweden,2016,pp.1041-1046.
 M.Revilloud,D.Gruyer,and M.C.Rahal, "A new multi-agent approach for lane detection and tracking," in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Robotics and Automation (ICRA),Stockholm,Sweden,2016,pp.3147-3153.
 M.Bertozzi,A.Broggi,A.Fascioli,and A.Tibaldi, "An evolutionary approach to lane markings detection in road environments," Atti del,vol.6,pp.627-636,Aug.2002.
 L.W.Tsai,J.W.Hsieh,C.H.Chuang,and K.C.Fan, "Lane detection using directional random walks," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Eindhoven,Netherlands,2008,pp.303-306.
 L.Bai and Y.Wang, "Road tracking using particle filters with partition sampling and auxiliary variables," Comput.Vis.Image Understand.,vol.115,no.10,pp.1463-1471,Oct.2011.
 R.Danescu and S.Nedevschi, "Probabilistic lane tracking in difficult road scenarios using stereovision," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.10,no.2,pp.272-282,Jun.2009.
 Z.Kim, "Robust lane detection and tracking in challenging scenarios," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.9,no.1,pp.16-26,Mar.2008.
 B.S.Shin,J.L.Tao,and R.Klette, "A superparticle filter for lane detection," Pattern Recogn.,vol.48,no.11,pp.3333-3345,Nov.2015.
 A.Das,S.S.Murthy,and U.Suddamalla, "Enhanced algorithm of automated ground truth generation and validation for lane detection system by M 2BMT," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.18,no.4,pp.996-1005,Apr.2017.
 R.Labayrade,S.S.Leng,and D.Aubert, "A reliable road lane detector approach combining two vision-based algorithms," in Proc.7th Int.IEEE Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems,Washington,WA,USA,2004,pp.149-154.
 R.Labayrade,J.Douret,J.Laneurit,and R.Chapuis, "A reliable and robust lane detection system based on the parallel use of three algorithms for driving safety assistance," IEICE Trans.Inform.Syst.,vol.E89-D,no.7,pp.2092-2100,Jul.2006.
 D.C.Hernández,D.Seo,and K.H.Jo, "Robust lane marking detection based on multi-feature fusion," in Proc.9th Int.Conf.Human System Interactions (HSI),Portsmouth,UK,2016,pp.423-428.
 Y.U.Yim and S.Y.Oh, "Three-feature based automatic lane detection algorithm (TFALDA) for autonomous driving," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.4,no.4,pp.219-225,Dec.2003.
 M.Felisa and P.Zani, "Robust monocular lane detection in urban environments," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV),San Diego,CA,USA,2010,pp.591-596.
 M.Bertozzi and A.Broggi, "GOLD:A parallel real-time stereo vision system for generic obstacle and lane detection," IEEE Trans.Image Process.,vol.7,no.1,pp.62-81,Jan.1998.
 A.S.Huang,D.Moore,M.Antone,E.Olson,and S.Teller, "Finding multiple lanes in urban road networks with vision and lidar," Auton.Robots,vol.26,no.2-3,pp.103-122,Apr.2009.
 H.Y.Cheng,B.S.Jeng,P.T.Tseng,and K.C.Fan, "Lane detection with moving vehicles in the traffic scenes," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.7,no.4,pp.571-582,Dec.2006.
 S.Sayanan and M.M.Trivedi, "Integrated lane and vehicle detection,localization,and tracking:A synergistic approach," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.14,no.2,pp.906-917,Jun.2013.
 C.F.Wu,C.J.Lin,and C.Y.Lee, "Applying a functional neurofuzzy network to real-time lane detection and front-vehicle distance measurement," IEEE Trans.Syst.,Man,Cybern.,Part C (Appl.Rev.),vol.42,no.4,pp.577-589,Jul.2012.
 S.S.Huang,C.J.Chen,P.Y.Hsiao,and L.C.Fu, "On-board vision system for lane recognition and front-vehicle detection to enhance driver's awareness," in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Robotics and Automation,New Orleans,LA,USA,vol.3,pp.2456-2461,Jul.2004.
 R.K.Satzoda and M.M.Trivedi, "Efficient lane and vehicle detection with integrated synergies (ELVIS)," in Proc.IEEE Conf.Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition Workshops (CVPRW),Columbus,OH,USA,2014,pp.708-713.
 H.Kim,Y.Lee,T.Woo,and H.Kim, "Integration of vehicle and lane detection for forward collision warning system," in Proc.6th Int.Conf.Consumer Electronics-Berlin (ICCE-Berlin),Berlin,Germany,2016,5-8.
 B.Qin,W.Liu,X.Shen,Z.J.Chong,T.Bandyopadhyay,M.H.Ang,E.Frazzoli,and D.Rus, "A general framework for road marking detection and analysis," in Proc.16th Int.IEEE Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems-(ITSC),The Hague,Netherlands,2013,pp.619-625.
 A.Kheyrollahi and T.P.Breckon, "Automatic real-time road marking recognition using a feature driven approach," Mach.Vis.Appl.,vol.23,no.1,pp.123-133,Jan.2012.
 J.Greenhalgh,and M.Mirmehdi, "Detection and recognition of painted road surface markings," in Proc.4th Int.Conf.Pattern Recognition Applications and Methods,Lisbon,Portugal,2015,pp.130-138.
 G.L.Oliveira,W.Burgard,and T.Brox, "Efficient deep models for monocular road segmentation," in Proc.IEEE/RSJ Int.Conf.Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS),Daejeon,South Korea,2016,pp.4885-4891.
 H.Kong,J.Y.Audibert,and J.Ponce, "Vanishing point detection for road detection," in Proc.IEEE Conf.Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition,Miami,FL,USA,2009,pp.96-103.
 L.Dan, "StixelNet:A deep convolutional network for obstacle detection and road segmentation," in Proc.26th British Machine Vision Conference,Swansea,UK,2015.
 G.P.Stein,Y.Gdalyahu,and A.Shashua, "Stereo-assist:Top-down stereo for driver assistance systems," in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.(IV),San Diego,CA,USA,2010,pp.723-730.
 E.Raphael and R.Kiefer, "Development of a camera-based forward collision alert system," SAE Int.J.Passeng.Cars-Mech.Syst.,vol.4,no.1,pp.467-478,Dec.2011.
 B.Ma,S.Lakahmanan,and A.Hero, "Road and lane edge detection with multisensor fusion methods," in Proc.Int.Conf.Image Processing,Kobe,Japan,vol.2,pp.686-690,Oct.1999.
 M.Beyeler,F.Mirus,and A.Verl, "Vision-based robust road lane detection in urban environments," in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Robotics and Automation (ICRA),Hong Kong,China,2014,pp.4920-4925.
 U.Ozgunalp,R.Fan,X.Ai,and N.Dahnoun, "Multiple lane detection algorithm based on novel dense vanishing point estimation," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.18,no.3,pp.621-632,Mar.2017.
 C.Lipski,B.Scholz,K.Berger,C.Linz,T.Stich,and M.Magnor, "A fast and robust approach to lane marking detection and lane tracking," in Proc.IEEE Southwest Symp.Image Analysis and Interpretation,Santa Fe,NM,USA,2008,pp.57-60.
 D.Kim,B.Kim,T.Chung,and K.Yi, "Lane-level localization using an AVM camera for an automated driving vehicle in urban environments," IEEE/ASME Trans.Mechatron.,vol.22,no.1,pp.280-290,Feb.2017.
 H.G.Jung,Y.H.Lee,H.J.Kang,and J.Kim, "Sensor fusion-based lane detection for LKS+ACC system," Int.J.Automot.Technol.,vol.10,no.2,pp.219-228,Apr.2009.
 D.X.Cui,J.R.Xue,and N.N.Zheng, "Real-time global localization of robotic cars in lane level via lane marking detection and shape registration," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.17,no.4,pp.1039-1050,Apr.2016.
 Y.Jiang,F.Gao,and G.Y.Xu, "Computer vision-based multiple-lane detection on straight road and in a curve," in Proc.Int.Conf.Image Analysis and Signal Processing (IASP),Zhejiang,China,2010,pp.114-117.
 C.Rose,J.Britt,J.Allen,and D.Bevly, "An integrated vehicle navigation system utilizing lane-detection and lateral position estimation systems in difficult environments for GPS," IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.15,no.6,pp.2615-2629,Dec.2014.
 Q.Q.Li,L.Chen,M.Li,S.L.Shaw,and A.Nuchter, "A sensor-fusion drivable-region and lane-detection system for autonomous vehicle navigation in challenging road scenarios," IEEE Trans.Veh.Technol., vol.63,no.2,pp.540-555,Feb.2014.
 S.Kammel and B.Pitzer,"Lidar-based lane marker detection and mapping,"in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Eindhoven,Netherlands,2008,pp.1137-1142.
 M.Manz,M.Himmelsbach,T.Luettel,and H.J.Wuensche,"Detection and tracking of road networks in rural terrain by fusing vision and LIDAR,"in Proc.IEEE/RSJ Int.Conf.Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS),San Francisco,CA,USA,2011,pp.4562-4568.
 M.Schreiber,C.Knoppel,and U.Franke,"Laneloc:Lane marking based localization using highly accurate maps,"in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.(IV),Gold Coast,QLD,Australia,2013,pp. 449-454.
 J.M.Clanton,D.M.Bevly,and A.S.Hodel,"A low-cost solution for an integrated multisensor lane departure warning system,"IEEE Trans. Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.10,no.1,pp.47-59,Mar.2009.
 M.Montemerlo,J.Becker,S.Bhat,H.Dahlkamp,D.Dolgov,S. Ettinger,D.Haehnel,T.Hilden,G.Hoffmann,B.Huhnke,D.Johnston, S.Klumpp,D.Langer,A.Levandowski,J.Levinson,J.Marcil,D. Orenstein,J.Paefgen,I.Penny,A.Petrovskaya,M.Pflueger,G.Stanek, D.Stavens,A.Vogt,and S.Thrun,"Junior:The stanford entry in the urban challenge,"J.Field Robot.,vol.25,no.9,pp.569-597,Sep. 2008.
 M.Buehler,K.Iagnemma,and S.Singh,The DARPA Urban Challenge:Autonomous Vehicles in City Traffic.Berlin Heidelberg,Germany:Springer,2009.
 P.Lindner,E.Richter,G.Wanielik,K.Takagi,and A.Isogai, "Multichannel lidar processing for lane detection and estimation," in Proc. 12th Int.IEEE Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems,St.Louis,MO, USA,2009,pp.1-6.
 S.Shin,I.Shim,and I.S.Kweon,"Combinatorial approach for lane detection using image and LIDAR reflectance,"in Proc.12th Int.Conf. Ubiquitous Robots and Ambient Intelligence (URAI),Goyang,South Korea,2015,pp.485-487.
 P.Amaradi,N.Sriramoju,L.Dang,G.S.Tewolde,and J.Kwon,"Lane following and obstacle detection techniques in autonomous driving vehicles,"in Proc.IEEE Int.Conf.Electro Information Technology (EIT),Grand Forks,ND,USA,2016,pp.674-679.
 D.Klaus,"Roadway detection and lane detection using multilayer laserscanner,"in Advanced Microsystems for Automotive Applications 2005,J.Valldorf,and W.Gessner,Eds.Berlin Heidelberg,Germany:Springer,2005,pp.197-213.
 D.C.Hernández,V.D.Hoang,and K.H.Jo,"Lane surface identification based on reflectance using laser range finder,"in Proc.IEEE/SICE Int.Symp.System Integration (SⅡ),Tokyo,Japan,2014,pp.621-625.
 J.Sparbert,K.Dietmayer,and D.Streller,"Lane detection and street type classification using laser range images,"in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems,Oakland,CA,USA,2001,pp.454-459.
 A.Broggi,S.Cattani,P.P.Porta,and P.Zani,"A laserscanner-vision fusion system implemented on the terramax autonomous vehicle,"in Proc.IEEE/RSJ Int.Conf.Intelligent Robots and Systems,Beijing, China,2006,pp.111-116.
 H.J.Zhao,M.Chiba,R.Shibasaki,X.W.Shao,J.S.Cui,and H.B. Zha,"A laser-scanner-based approach toward driving safety and traffic data collection,"IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.10,no.3,pp. 534-546,Sep.2009.
 A.Borkar,M.Hayes,and M.T.Smith,"A novel lane detection system with efficient ground truth generation,"IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp. Syst.,vol.13,no.1,pp.365-374,Mar.2012.
 C.W.Lin,H.Y.Wang,and D.C.Tseng,"A robust lane detection and verification method for intelligent vehicles,"in Proc.3rd Int.Symp. Intelligent Information Technology Application,Shanghai,China,vol. 1,pp.521-524,Nov.2009.
 J.H.Yoo,S.W.Lee,S.K.Park,and D.H.Kim,"A robust lane detection method based on vanishing point estimation using the relevance of line segments,"IEEE Trans.Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.18, no.12,pp.3254-3266,Dec.2017.
 L.Li,W.L.Huang,Y.H.Liu,N.N.Zheng,and F.Y.Wang, Intelligence testing for autonomous vehicles:A new approach,"IEEE Trans.Intell.Veh.,vol.1,no.2,pp.158-166,Jun.2016.
 K.C.Kluge,"Performance evaluation of vision-based lane sensing:Some preliminary tools,metrics,and results,"in Proc.Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems,Boston,MA,USA,1997,pp.723-728.
 T.Veit,J.P.Tarel,P.Nicolle,and P.Charbonnier,"Evaluation of road marking feature extraction,"in Proc.11th Int.IEEE Conf.Intelligent Transportation Systems,Beijing,China,2008,pp.174-181.
 J.C.McCall and M.M.Trivedi,"Performance evaluation of a vision based lane tracker designed for driver assistance systems,"in Proc. Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Las Vegas,NV,USA,2005,pp.153-158.
 R.K.Satzoda and M.M.Trivedi,"On performance evaluation metrics for lane estimation,"in Proc.22nd Int.Conf.Pattern Recognition, Stockholm,Sweden,2014,pp.2625-2630.
 C.R.Jung and C.R.Kelber,"A robust linear-parabolic model for lane following,"in Proc.17th Brazilian Symp.Computer Graphics and Image Processing,Curitiba,Brazil,2004,pp.72-79.
 M.Haloi and D.B.Jayagopi,"A robust lane detection and departure warning system,"in Proc.IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symp.,Seoul, South Korea,2015,pp.126-131.
 F.Y.Wang,"Parallel system methods for management and control of complex systems,"Control Dec.,vol.19,no.5,pp.485-489,514, May 2004.
 F.Y.Wang, "Parallel control and management for intelligent transportation systems:Concepts,architectures,and applications," IEEE Trans. Intell.Transp.Syst.,vol.11,no.3,pp.630-638,Sep.2010.
 F.Y.Wang, "Artificial societies,computational experiments,and parallel systems:A discussion on computational theory of complex socialeconomic systems," Complex Syst.Complexity Sci.,vol.1,no.4,pp. 25-35,Oct.2004.
 L.Li,Y.L.Lin,D.P.Cao,N.N.Zheng,and F.Y.Wang,"Parallel learning-a new framework for machine learning,"Acta Autom.Sinica, vol.43,no.1,pp.1-8,Jan.2017.
 K.F.Wang,C.Gou,N.N.Zheng,J.M.Rehg,and F.Y.Wang, Parallel vision for perception and understanding of complex scenes:Methods,framework,and perspectives,"Artif.Intell.Rev.,vol.48,no. 3,pp.299-329,Oct.2017.
 F.Y.Wang,N.N.Zheng,D.P.Cao,C.M.Martinez,L.Li,and T.Liu, Parallel driving in CPSS:A unified approach for transport automation and vehicle intelligence,"IEEE/CAA J.Autom.Sinica,vol.4,no.4, pp.577-587,Sep.2017.
 C.Lv,Y.H.Liu,X.S.Hu,H.Y.Guo,D.P.Cao,and F.Y.Wang, Simultaneous observation of hybrid states for cyber-physical systems:A case study of electric vehicle powertrain,"IEEE Trans.Cybern., 2018,to be published,doi:10.1109/TCYB.2017.2738003.
 D.Silver,A.Huang,C.J.Maddison,A.Guez,L.Sifre,G.van den Driessche,J.Schrittwieser,I.Antonoglou,V.Panneershelvam, M.Lanctot,S.Dieleman,D.Grewe,J.Nham,N.Kalchbrenner,I. Sutskever,T.Lillicrap,M.Leach,K.Kavukcuoglu,T.Graepel,and D. Hassabis,"Mastering the game of Go with deep neural networks and tree search,"Nature,vol.529,no.7587,pp.484-489,Jan.2016.